Charlie and the Chocolate Factory - Roald Dahl
Thursday, November 16th, 2006One cannot talk about Chocolate and popular culture without talking about Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. From my former post, you can see that over thirty three thousand of you are looking for either the book or the movie.
The Book
When I was a kid, my mom gave me a copy of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory by Roald Daul (same cover as below - the 1964 version). It was one of the first books I read from cover to cover (and still have on my bookshelf downstairs). His descriptions were lively and playful, and you could tell that he was thinking like a child would. I read all of his books and even attempted a “Georges Marvelous Medicine” of my own. It didn’t really do anything “marvelous” to me, but rather made me sick to my stomach. Now that I think about it, I probably shouldn’t have drank that solution in the first place.
The Movie(s)
I loved the movie as a kid - the tales of a somewhat crazed chocolate maker who let a few children into his chocolate factory and divulged his somewhat strange secrets on making chocolate and other candies. As I’ve read the book “Emperors of Chocolate” over the past couple months, it’s interesting to see how much of the secrecy of the Hershey and Mars Families inspired this kind of literary work.

Over the past couple weeks I’ve gotten the inkling to see the original Charlie and the Chocolate Factory again, and haven’t been able to locate it in any of the local video rentals or department stores. (They seem to be overflowing with the newest version) So I ordered it on Amazon. While I thought Johnny Depp’s portrayal of Willy Wonka was a lot of fun, and the visuals to the show were quite superior to the original, I didn’t like what they had done to the storyline at all. In the original the whole story surrounding the “bad” guy who wanted a sample of the everlasting gobstopper carried me through the movie and gave it a deeper story line. In the remake it seems that either Willy Wonka was the bad guy, or perhaps his childhood upbringing, but either way I didn’t lack the thread that I was looking for to hold the somewhat tragic occurrences to each child.
I ran across this link the other day that I found interesting. Hand it to Wikipedi to have a whole section on the differences between the book, and both film versions of Charlie. It’s a fun read of your a Charlie buff.
The Lost Chapter?
I also ran across an article talking about the “lost chapter” that intended to be in the book which featured Miranda Piker, but was cut by the publishers of the book. The chapter dealt with implied cannibalism and was cut due to the character’s grotesque ‘elimination,’ which was more violent than those of the other naughty children. The chapter recently resurfaced, and is located at the Times Online.
So which is your favorite version of the movie? And favorite treat? Do rivers of chocolate flow into your life occasionally? Or do you wish you could have a whole meal in one piece of chewing gum?


